This week, Francois Perrin made one of his semi-annual visits to Tablas Creek. We always like to see Francois after harvest; it gives us our first outside perspective on the most recent vintage, and gives us a chance to bounce the ideas we had during crush off of someone whose experience with these grapes is unmatched. We also typically taste through the blends of the previous vintage of red wine, to decide if all is well or if any of them need some final adjustments.
Blending the 2010 reds was unusual because they are still in their component pieces in November, more than a year after harvest. Typically, we've made our blending decisions on the previous vintage's red wines by early summer, and they're blended and sitting quietly in foudre for the subsequent harvest. But this year, thanks to the late 2010 harvest and the cold 2010-2011 winter, the wines weren't ready to be evaluated in the late spring. When my dad returned to Vermont in late May we'd only been able to taste through and identify the lots that we were going to declassify into the 2010 Patelin de Tablas. But as for the decisions beyond that first cut -- i.e. should this Mourvedre lot go into Panoplie, Esprit, Cotes or varietal Mourvedre -- we just didn't feel confident making them while the wines were still finishing up their fermentations. [You can read the blog post I wrote in May with my initial impressions of the 2010 reds] So, we put the wines to bed as components and awaited my dad's October return from Vermont, knowing that we were unlikely to be able to turn our attention to blending the 2010's until the 2011 harvest was complete.
So the last two weeks have been blending weeks. It was a relatively easy blending (much easier than was the blending of the 2010 whites) thanks to how finished the wines were and to the fact that the first cut of friendly but less impressive lots had already been made. I took notes on the wines during our final run-through with Francois yesterday, and have noted some comments by the others who were in the room. For the tasting, my dad, Francois and I were joined by our winemaking team of Neil, Ryan and Chelsea, as well as National Sales Manager Tommy Oldre and Francois' son Cesar, who is in the middle of a year here at Tablas Creek. We began with a flight of the varietal wines, and moved on to the blends. The lineup:
2010 Grenache: Spicy, peppery nose with strawberry fruit lurking behind and coming out -- along with a floral note -- more and more with air. On the palate at first fruity, then nice acids, then an appealing loamy character. Juiciness and tannins both come out on the finish. Neil called it "very fresh, very clean" and Chelsea thought it had a "nice, friendly affability". I was impressed with how evocative of Grenache it was: not a blockbuster, but classic.
2010 Mourvedre: Rich on the nose, with pepper steak, bitter chocolate, and dark red fruit. The mouth is plummy with a nice earthy richness, chewy tannins and a moderate-length, slightly cedary finish right now. Francois called it "closed but deep". I thought it was the least giving of the varietals now, but also right in keeping with where Mourvedres usually are at this stage. It will benefit from 6 more months in foudre.
2010 Syrah: Dense & inky nose, minty and chocolatey, with a touch of iodine-like minerality. The mouth was rich with black, tangy fruit and chalky tannins. This has nice vibrancy for Syrah, reflective of the cool 2010 vintage. There's a long finish with a touch of oak that will surely integrate more in time. Cesar called it "classic syrah". My dad thought it tasted like Cornas.
2010 Cotes de Tablas (46% Grenache, 39% Syrah, 10% Mourvedre, 5% Counoise): A fruity, spicy, brambly purple fruit nose, with sweet spices like nutmeg and cinnamon coming out with air. The mouth is nicely vibrant, with plum and loam and a nice generosity, framed by good acids. An impression of sweetness on the finish, though it's a dry wine. Chelsea said "I'm ready to take this home and drink this with dinner today" and Cesar thought "everybody can like this". A great showing for the Cotes... maybe our best yet.
2010 En Gobelet (35% Mourvedre, 31% Grenache, 13% Syrah, 11% Counoise, 10% Tannat): Very dark in color. A slightly tarry nose, with black and purple fruits lurking behind. The mouth is first sweet fruit, then savory and somehow feral, then tannic with some oak, rounding out with a surprisingly gentle finish. Clearly big but needs to develop. Neil called it "Rustic but in a good way" and Cesar thought it "closed but with beautiful potential". I was least sure where this was going, but I know it will be impressive.
2010 Esprit de Beaucastel (45% Mourvedre, 30% Grenache, 21% Syrah, 4% Counoise): Dark and backward on the nose, not yet giving much away other than a little oak and a sense of inky richness. The mouth is broader and richer than the nose suggests, with a really nice mouthfeel and a very long finish where in turn dark red fruit, chalk, tannins and a tangy soy/teriyaki character take the fore. Francois called it "great but definitely needs some time". I thought it was terrific in its sense of power held in reserve, and can't wait to see it develop.
2010 Panoplie (60% Mourvedre, 30% Grenache, 10% Syrah): Very different and much more exuberant on the nose than the Esprit. Big, spicy nose with lots of purple fruit and an appealing mintiness. The mouth is velvety and rich, with an initial impression of sweet fruit gradually drawn back into big tannins. Francois thought it "not polite yet but powerful potential". My dad thought it showed nice Mourvedre character. I thought it both bigger and less finished than the Esprit, and definitely a wine that will benefit from its time in foudre.
We'll make a few other wines from the 2010 vintage, including our first Counoise since 2006, our first-ever Cabernet, our Tannat and a couple different small-production Pinot Noirs, but those components mostly weren't candidates for these blends, so we didn't taste them again with Francois. I'll post notes when we're getting closer to bottling them.
A few final thoughts. This was an impressive tasting, and all the wines showed a coolness and a vibrancy that seems to be a hallmark of the 2010 vintage. This plays into our hands, as we tend to gravitate toward wines that are more about their balance and their restraint than about their sheer power. I thought that all these wines are going to age beautifully, particularly those based on Mourvedre.
We're offering the 2010 Esprit and the 2010 Panoplie now as part of our en primeur futures program, and we'll be tasting the wines with 125 or so of our club members this Saturday. I'm very much looking forward to sharing them in public for the first time and seeing what people think.