Our Most Memorable Wines of 2024
December 31, 2024
As I have done the last few years, I asked our team to share a wine or two that stuck with them from all the ones they'd tried in 2024, and why. This is always one of my favorite blogs to put together. I love seeing the breadth of wine interests of the Tablas Creek team. More than that, I love seeing what inspired them. If you don't work at a winery, you might expect that those of us who do spend most of our time drinking our own wines, but in my experience, that's far from the case. Most people who find a career in wine do so because they find it fascinating, and that interest doesn't go away just because they've landed at a particular winery, even a winery that they love. And most people who work at wineries look at exploring other wines as an enjoyable form of continuing education.
Each time I put this list together, I'm reminded of the degree to which the memorableness of a wine is tied to the occasion for which and the company with whom it was opened. That's one of the magical things about wine. It comes in a serving size that is meant to be shared. Most of the best wines shine particularly brightly with food. So opening a bottle of wine is a shared experience that unfolds over time. It fosters conversation and connection. And because each wine is alive revisiting one can be like checking in with an old friend.
Here's everyone's submission, in their own words and only very lightly edited, in alphabetical order (except mine, which is at the end, with some concluding thoughts):
Charlie Chester, Senior Assistant Tasting Room Manager
My most memorable wine wasn't the rarest or most expensive this year. It was a 2019 L.A. Cetto Nebbiolo enjoyed during our honeymoon on the coast of Oaxaca, Mexico, this past January.
Amber and I escaped the cold, wet winter of Paso Robles and spent ten unforgettable days exploring the Oaxacan coast, from Puerto Escondido to Bahia de La Luna. We dined at a 5-star restaurant overlooking the Pacific Ocean, savoring a fantastic meal alongside the Nebbiolo.
Sharing that bottle with my wife as the sun dipped below the horizon created a memory that goes beyond the wine itself. It's a reminder of our incredible journey through coastal Oaxaca and the magic of shared experiences. This experience showed me that the best times with wine can be more about the people, the place, and the feeling. These things can make a simple bottle of wine truly special.
Neil Collins, Director of Winemaking
Most memorable wine of the year. This is never easy because we do enjoy lots of bottles over the course of a year, and I have a sieve-like memory!!
I'm going to break the rules because sometimes one must! I'm going with a whole experience, I was able to visit Domaine Weinbach in Alsace with a group from Lone Madrone, during a Rhine River Cruise. I have wanted to visit Weinbach for decades. It did not disappoint, if there is a better white wine producer anywhere I have not been there! We poured Cuvée Catherine from magnum on the ship that night, perfect. The second is another cruise-related wine. We became very good friends with a couple on the first Tablas Rhone River cruise. We were visiting them in Carlsbad recently and they shared a bottle that they had picked up on a shore trip from a later cruise. A Chapoutier Hermitage Chante Alouette (Marsanne) 2014, it was stunning.
Ian Consoli, Director of Marketing
I enjoyed a lot of good wine in many fun situations in 2024. I participated in wine dinners, blind tastings, and good old-fashioned tableside chats with friends. The one wine that stands out was this 2014 Oveja Negra from Lone Madrone paired with Tablas Creek lamb. We had multiple heavy-hitting wines with that meal, but I just kept coming back to the pairing. My opinion is probably skewed from my host saying her goal was to make my most memorable wines of the year list, but hey, it worked, Lisa!
Terrence Crowe, Tasting Room
Some of the most memorable wines for me each year are thought provoking options that generally have a few years of cellar time prior to consumption. This year I opened a Tablas Creek 2011 Antithesis and was pleasantly surprised. It was one of those vintages from Paso where cellar time seemed necessary across the board. A delicate vintage that was less than showy upon release. The antithesis was one of those wines that never particularly drove my immediate interest in the tasting room upon release. This 2011 antithesis with extended bottle age was fantastic. The sheer joy I get from aged Roussanne and Chardonnay is profound. The day two pour of the 2011 antithesis did not disappoint either.
The other memorable wines consist of a few magnum bottles bestowed upon me by Tablas Creek. For the holidays I received a 2015 Esprit Rouge and a 2015 Esprit Blanc offering in magnum format. The Esprits are world-class, highly age-worthy renditions that embody the essence of Tablas Creek vineyards. The overall generosity and my sheer enjoyment in the series with a few years in bottle couple to make this a truly fantastic gift. Gratitude and gustatory delight will exude outwardly as I consume these large format bottles in an optimal window for mass appeal.
Chelsea Franchi, Senior Assistant Winemaker
My husband and I got married on October 9, which is planted squarely in the middle of the harvest season. That means every year it’s a toss-up to see if we’ll get to celebrate on our actual anniversary or if we’ll celebrate on a later (less busy) date. This year, we were able to go out to dinner on the real day, and it was spectacular. We went to Six Test Kitchen, an intimate Michelin-starred restaurant nestled in Tin City here in Paso Robles. We had Champagne with the earlier, lighter courses, and for the richer, meatier courses, we brought along a bottle of 2015 Ridge Monte Bello. The wine was dense and chewy with intensely powerful purple and black fruit, plenty of herb and spice as well as the distinctive Ridge American oak nerve that was seamlessly laced through the wine. The whole evening, we couldn’t help but laugh every time we smelled the wine or took a sip; in that atmosphere, with that food and company, the wine was absolutely perfect. It always feels like a treat to have Ridge on the dinner table, but this night with this meal and this wine, was one of those magic moments.
Barbara Haas, Co-Founder
I don't remember every wine I drank this year, but I can't imagine a better wine than the 1988 Clos de la Roche of Ponsot that we drank with Christmas dinner. Perfectly balanced, quiet but complex, no element stealing the scene from another. Clear clean aroma and taste and great length. Delicious.
Ray King, Tasting Room
My most memorable wines of 2024 came all in one evening. The league of extraordinary gentlemen (a local group of wine and restaurant industry folks) were having dinner at Les Petites Canailles. The wines were flawless and all had a proper spot for this excellent dinner with great friends.
John Morris, Tasting Room Manager
My most memorable wine(s) of the year are again in-house, partially because I didn't taste as far and wide as usual, and partially because Tablas Creek wines are so darn good. But first, some background.
As part of ongoing tasting room staff training, we indulged ourselves in a random sampling of Esprit de Tablas/Beaucastel Blanc, from as far back as 2000. While a few stood out (2004, 2010, 2015, 2017), I was most excited about something that doesn't fully exist yet: a barrel sample of the 2023 Esprit de Tablas Blanc. This wine was so pure, so balanced, and so, yes, exciting - thrilling even - at this early stage that I literally can't wait for it to be bottled so I can taste it again. VINsiders - look for a bottle to be included in your fall 2025 shipment.
Followers of this page may know that we launched an elevated tasting this summer, the Legacy Tasting. This tasting offers an opportunity to taste new and old Esprits and Panoplies side by side. We've been thrilled with the results, but selfishly, the opportunity to taste the 2017 Panoplie as we open bottles for this tasting has been revelatory. For my money this may be the single best bottle we've yet produced.
...And As for Me
I spent more time on the road this year than I have in two decades. Some of that was because after a few scarce vintages we finally had enough wine to sell. Some of it was because I identified early in the year that export markets were likely to be a growth opportunity and was lucky enough to be invited to represent Paso Robles on a California Wine Institute tour to Japan and Korea. And some of it was because I made a point to go and visit Beaucastel and see the remarkable cellar that they have spent the last four years building. As my travel plans came into focus, I found myself with a few days to fill between commitments in the UK and my arrival in the Rhone. I decided to spend those days working with our German importer, Veritable Vins et Domaines, and was invited to arrive a day early to spend a day exploring the Rheingau with Christian Ress, co-founder of Veritable and fifth-generation proprietor of Balthasar Ress. I've long loved German Riesling, but had never visited wine country there. With Christian, I got to explore the vineyards on a glorious late fall day, and then taste through a range of his Rieslings. The experience was incredible, and the wines superb.
As great as all those Balthasar Ress wines were, I'm not picking one as my most memorable wine. It's incredibly difficult to have a wine of which you only got a taste be the most memorable, or one of a dozen wines you might have had at a tasting. But the experience definitely primed me for what I am choosing. About a month after I got home, I made an old-fashioned Chinese recipe that my dad used to love from the Craig Claiborne and Virginia Lee's seminal 1972 The Chinese Cookbook.
To pair with the dish (chicken in tomato sauce with water chestnuts, garlic, and ginger) I was looking for a wine with verve and texture and just a hint of sweetness. I ended up picking a wine I'd been sent by a friend who once worked a harvest here at Tablas Creek before jumping into a career in wine retail and eventually distribution. It was the 2020 Peter Lauer Ayler Kupp Stirn Riesling Fass 15 Grosse Lage, a Grand Cru Riesling from the Saar region about 125 miles west of where I'd been in the Rheingau. I was expecting something good, and the wine was more than that. It was electric. There was sweetness, yes, but also vibrant acids, plentiful fruit, and a lovely saline note that I still feel like I can taste, two weeks later. It transformed the meal into something exceptional, and was a fascinating wine to discuss with everyone from my boys, who are just learning about wine, to my mother-in-law, who normally doesn't like sweet wines, to my wife Meghan, who has been alongside many of my most fascinating wine journeys over the last three decades.
A few concluding thoughts:
I did my best to link each wine to a page with information about it, should you want to research details. And while all these wines should be remarkable if you are able to find them, I don't think replicating a specific wine is necessarily the right goal. If there's one thing that I've learned from writing these end-of-year appreciations for a decade now, it's that it really is the confluence of wine and occasion that makes for the most memorable experiences. Wine, after all, is the ultimate social beverage. The size of a bottle means it's something that you share with others. The fact that wine is ephemeral, that each bottle is a reflection of particular grapes grown in a particular place in a particular vintage, means that each one is different and also a unique reflection of time and place. Add in the human element, where the winemaker or winemakers are taking (or not taking) actions based on what they see, smell, and taste, and you have what is in essence a time capsule that comes with the added benefit of helping you enjoy a meal and bring insight into the flavors it contains. It's the perfect starting point for a meaningful evening, and helps bring the food and the people together.
I wish you all memorable food and wine experiences in 2025, and even more than that, the opportunity to share them with people you love.