Tasting the Wines in the Spring 2025 VINsider Wine Club Shipments
February 12, 2025
Each spring and fall, we send out a selection of six wines to the members of our VINsider Wine Club. In many cases, these are wines that only go out to our club. Most of these (including five of the six wines in the classic shipment and five of the six additional wines we added to the Red Wine Selection and White Wine Selection shipments) are made in quantities of 1,000 cases or less. At least a month before the club shipments will be sent out, Neil and I open them all to write the tasting and production notes that will be included in the club shipments. In many cases, this tasting is our first post-bottling reintroduction (or our last pre-bottling check-in) on wines that we'll come to know intimately in coming months and years. I always think it's fun to give followers of the blog a first look at these notes. I love this candid photo that Ian took of me and Neil before we knew we were supposed to be posing with the wines. I hope it gives you a sense of how much we enjoyed the tasting:
The shipments that will be going out in March include wines from the 2022, 2023, and 2024 vintages. Tasting three vintages together is a great way to get a handle on their relative personalities, and typically my first chance to do a personality assessment on the newest vintage, on which we haven't even started blending trials yet. My quick thoughts, after the tasting, are:
- Although 2022 was our hottest year ever, the wines don't taste like you'd probably expect. Instead, there's a freshness and openness to even our most age-worthy reds that gives confirmation that we were able to keep up with the year's pressures and get the grapes off the vine in good shape. But the combination of spring frosts, drought, and unrelenting heat meant that harvest was so scarce that there were several wines we just couldn't make.
- The wines from the unusually cool, even 2023 season continue to demonstrate that this was an outstanding year across the board, from early-drinking whites to ageworthy reds. The wines all show deep colors, complexity, purity, and expressiveness. A lovely combination and a pleasure of a vintage.
- With only the first few wines, it's early to generalize about 2024, but the Vermentino and Dianthus show noteworthy lushness, but with bright acids to balance them. This is perhaps unsurprising from a year with a cool first half and a hot conclusion.
I'll go through the six wines in the VINsider Classic (Mixed) Shipment and then move on to the additional wines we chose to include in the Red Wine Selection and White Wine Selection shipments. The Classic Shipment includes six different wines:
2023 COTES DE TABLAS BLANC
- Production Notes: After sacrificing the Cotes de Tablas Blanc in the painfully short 2022 vintage, it was a treat to have it back in the lineup. Viognier (34%) is always the lead grape in our Cotes Blanc, but the number two grape depends on the year. In the cool, slow-ripening 2023 vintage we ended up deciding to prioritize Marsanne (31%) for its elegance and luscious texture, with a bit less focus on Grenache Blanc (20%) in a year that naturally brought plenty of acid. Smaller additions of Roussanne (13%, for structure) and Clairette Blanche (2%, for minerality) round out the blend. The selected lots were blended in May 2024, and the wine was bottled that June.
- Tasting Notes: A lovely tropical nose of pineapple, nectarine, green herbs, and limestone. The mouth is rich but vibrant, with flavors of apricot, lime leaf, lanolin, and wet stone minerality. The wine's texture shines on the long, clean finish, leaving a lingering hint of apple skin tannin, sweet spice, and creamy minerality. Drink now and for at least the next five years.
- Production: 1330 cases.
- List Price: $40 VINsider Price: $32
2024 DIANTHUS
- Production Notes: With yields about 20% below average in 2024, and Mourvedre particularly scarce, we reduced the quantity of Dianthus by about 30% and evened up the percentages of our two lead grapes. Named after a family of flowering plants with deep pink blooms, Dianthus is always led by Mourvedre (44% this year), for rich texture and watermelon and plum fruit, with Grenache (43%) for bright strawberry fruit and refreshing acidity. Smaller additions of Counoise (9%) and Cinsaut (4%) bring brambly fruit and sweet spice to the blend. The fruit spent 36-48 hours on the skins, and then it completed its fermentation in stainless steel before bottling in January 2025.
- Tasting Notes: A beautiful deep peach color. On the nose, an appealing mix of yellow raspberry and yellow roses, cranberry and sweet spice. The mouth is luscious but electric too, with flavors of raspberry and salted watermelon, creamy texture, and a vibrant line of acidity that leaves a lingering impression of plum skin and briny sea spray. A rosé to convert people who don't think pink wines can be serious. Drink before the end of 2026.
- Production: 999 cases
- List Price: $40 VINsider Price: $32
2023 COUNOISE
- Production Notes: Valued as a blending grape in France because of its spiciness, its fresh acidity, and its low alcohol, Counoise is rarely seen on its own. But we love being able to share one, and suggest you enjoy it much as you might a Cru Beaujolais: slightly chilled, with charcuterie or as an aperitif. We tend to ferment our Counoise lots in stainless steel to protect them from oxidation, and to age them in neutral oak to avoid weighing down the grape's bright fruit flavors. The lots that we chose for our varietal Counoise were selected and blended in June 2024, aged in neutral 1200-gallon foudres (large oak barrels), and bottled in February 2025 under screwcap to preserve the wine's freshness.
- Tasting Notes: A vibrant garnet color, a shade darker than recent years. The nose shows brambly raspberry fruit with additional notes of rose hips, red licorice, and cola. The mouth is classic, with flavors of cranberry, cocoa powder, and wild strawberry, complete with fruit, leaves, and flowers. The long finish showcases a little burst of dusty tannins and leaves impressions of red fruit and flinty minerality. Enjoy it lightly chilled any time in the next four to six years.
- Production: 985 cases
- List Price: $40 VINsider Price: $32
2022 TANNAT
- Production Notes: Our varietal bottling of this traditional grape from southwest France, famous for its intense fruit, spice, and tannins that produce wines capable of long aging. Tannat is known principally in the Pyrenees foothills appellation of Madiran, but originally native to the Basque region. We ferment Tannat in open-top fermenters to keep it exposed to oxygen and start the softening process, then move it to neutral oak foudre where it ages for nearly 2 years. The wine was bottled in April 2024 and has been aging the last 10 months in bottle, waiting for its release.
- Tasting Notes: A powerful nose of minty dark chocolate, black cherry, and anise over a deep balsamic note. The palate is powerful and structured with flavors of licorice root, cedary oak, leather, and blackberry. The finish shows the wine's powerful tannins and acids and leaves a lingering spicy impression like a winter walk through a pine forest. Pair with rich foods now or age for up to two decades if you're looking for a more refined experience.
- Production: 822 cases
- List Price: $50 VINsider Price: $40
2022 LE COMPLICE
- Production Notes: The seventh vintage of our blend that celebrates the kinship between Syrah (67%) and two of our newest grapes: Terret Noir (5%) and Muscardin (3%). Le Complice means, roughly, "partner in crime". Although Syrah is dark and both Terret and Muscardin light, all three share wild herby black spice, with the higher acids of Terret and Muscardin leavening Syrah's tendency toward monolithic darkness. As usual, we added Grenache (25%) for friendliness and mid-palate generosity. The wine was blended in June of 2023, aged in foudre until its bottling in April 2024, and aged in bottle since then.
- Tasting Notes: A nose of bay, boysenberry, iron, and pancetta. On the palate, more open than the nose suggests, with flavors of dark plum, baker's chocolate, aromatic bitters, and a molasses-but-not-sweet note like pumpernickel bread. The finish shows chewy tannins, dark fruit, and a graphite mineral note classic for Syrah. Drink over the next two decades.
- Production: 785 cases
- List Price: $65 VINsider Price: $52
2022 PANOPLIE
- Production Notes: Panoplie is selected from the top 3% of the year's lots, chosen for their richness, concentration and balance. Mourvedre (67%) plays the starring role, bringing dark red fruit and its distinctive meaty, chocolatey richness. Roughly equal parts Grenache (18%, for sweet spice and vibrancy) and Syrah (15%, for black fruit, density, and tannic richness) complete the blend. Each lot was fermented individually before being selected, blended and moved to foudre to age in July 2023. The wine aged an additional 17 months before bottling in December 2024.
- Tasting Notes: A rich and appealing nose of plum compote, baking spices, sweet tobacco, and a violet-like florality. The mouth is lovely with flavors of currant and red licorice, mouth-filling texture, and a Mourvedre's signature loamy autumnal note, like a November hardwood forest hike. The long finish has notes of dark plum and sweet spice, and tannins with the texture of powdered sugar that we find in our best lots. A baby, but already delicious. Enjoy over the next two decades or longer.
- Production: 779 cases
- List Price: $105 VINsider Price: $84
Four additional wines (2024 Vermentino, 2023 Patelin de Tablas Blanc, and 2023 Viognier, and 2023 Roussanne) will join the 2023 Cotes Blanc and the 2024 Dianthus in the White Wine Selection shipment:
2024 VERMENTINO
- Production Notes: Our varietal bottling of this traditional Mediterranean variety, known principally in Sardinia, Corsica, and Northern Italy. It is also grown in the Mediterranean parts of France (particularly Côtes de Provence) where it is known as Rolle. The Vermentino grape produces wines that are bright, clean, and crisp, with distinctive citrus character and refreshing acidity. To emphasize this freshness, we ferment and age Vermentino in stainless steel, and bottle it young (January 2025, this vintage) under screwcap. Vermentino yields in 2024 were about 25% below our historical averages, and combined with the warm year to produce remarkable lushness and tropicality.
- Tasting Notes: A luscious nose of lemon drop, passion fruit, sea spray and sweet green herbs. The palate has mouth-filling texture, with flavors of gooseberry and crystallized pineapple and a focused saline mineral note that lingers into the long finish, underpinning additional notes of tropical fruit and jasmine-like florality. Drink now and over the next few years.
- Production: 838 cases
- List Price: $35 VINsider Price: $28
2023 PATELIN DE TABLAS BLANC
- Production Notes: Patelin is French slang for "neighborhood" and the Patelin de Tablas Blanc is our white Rhone-style blend of six grapes sourced from seven great neighboring Rhone vineyards: New Creations, Derby, Summerwood, Duas Terras, Templeton Preserve, Nevarez, and Creston Ridge, with a small addition of Tablas Creek fruit. We base the wine on the richness and acidity of Grenache Blanc (50%), with Viognier (23%) providing lush stone fruit and floral notes, Roussanne (10%) and Marsanne (8%) adding minerality and structure, and two bright grapes finishing the blend: Vermentino (8%) and Bourboulenc (1%). The wine was fermented entirely in stainless steel and then bottled under screwcap in May 2024 to preserve its freshness.
- Tasting Notes: A very Rhone-like nose of fresh apricot, finger lime, and a warm richness like a wheat field in the sun, balanced by a pithy Grenache Blanc textural note. On the palate, a gorgeous balance of bright and rich, with notes of quince and all the parts of a key lime pie, from fruit to a rich saline note that reminded us of salted graham cracker crust. The long, clean finish has notes of peach, jasmine, and white flowers. Drink now and over the next few years.
- Production: 4180 cases
- List Price: $28 VINsider Price: $22.40
2023 VIOGNIER
- Production Notes: Viognier is the northern Rhone's noble white grape, renowned for its floral intensity and lushness. It's also widely planted in California, with more acreage than all other Rhone whites combined. While we get a range of Viognier styles off the property, we prefer our Viognier on the more elegant, mineral-driven side and so aim our lusher lots to the Cotes de Tablas Blanc, where we can leaven that character with Grenache Blanc and Marsanne. For our varietal Viognier we chose one high-toned lot, fermented in a neutral 600-gallon foudre, and bottled it in June 2024.
- Tasting Notes: A bright, arresting nose of grilled lemon, coriander seed, citrus blossom, and ginger. The palate is fresh with flavors of pineapple and white pepper, salted nectarine and sweetgrass. Rich texture is balanced by excellent acids and a pure, elegant finish. Drink now and for at least the next five years.
- Production: 156 cases.
- List Price: $45 VINsider Price: $36
2023 ROUSSANNE
- Production Notes: Roussanne yields in 2022 were pummeled by our May frost, and we ended up sacrificing our varietal Roussanne and using every drop of estate Roussanne in our Esprit de Tablas Blanc. In 2023, yields remained low as our largest block of Roussanne recovered from the previous year's frost damage, but what we got was outstanding, and we were thrilled that our blending trials allowed us to make a small Roussanne bottling. The selected lots (roughly 60% from 132-gallon puncheons and 40% from 60-gallon barriques, about 50% new) were blended in April 2024 then aged in one neutral 600-gallon foudre through the subsequent harvest before bottling this past December.
- Tasting Notes: A classic chartreuse color: golden with just a hint of green. The appealingly spicy nose shows notes of honeysuckle, citrus blossom, cinnamon, and sweet oak. On the palate, rich but still very fresh, with flavors of poached pear, fresh honey, mace, lanolin, and white peach. The finish shows lovely lift, with a little minty note giving way to lingering impressions of fresh coconut and white flowers. Drink in the next 3 or 4 years for a pure expression of Roussanne's honey and pear flavors, or hold it for 8-15 years for a flavor profile of caramel, wet rocks, and hazelnut.
- Production: 259 cases
- List Price: $55 VINsider Price: $44
Two additional reds (the 2022 Mourvedre and the 2022 Syrah) join the 2023 Counoise, 2022 Panoplie, 2022 Le Complice, and 2022 Tannat in the Red Wine Selection shipment:
2022 MOURVEDRE
- Production Notes: We try to bottle a varietal Mourvedre each year, because we think it is a wonderful grape that too few people know, and one we feel worthy of some proselytizing. The hot 2022 vintage produced Mourvedre lots with a comparatively light color. Don't let that throw you; the flavors are both classic and intense. All our Mourvedre lots were fermented in large wooden tanks and moved to neutral barrels to await blending. We chose three lots that highlighted Mourvedre's higher-toned spice and red fruit elements, blended them in the spring of 2023, then aged the wine half in neutral 60-gallon barriques and half in one 475-gallon concrete egg before reassembling and bottling the wine in April 2024.
- Tasting Notes: A pretty ruby color. On the nose, spicy, almost alpine notes of juniper and thyme, over lingonberry and crushed rock. On the palate, flavors of Santa Rosa plum, milk chocolate, red raspberry and cranberry sauce. The bright finish shows notes of dried rose petals, red fruit, and spice. The wine's brightness suggests to us that you drink this earlier than most of our Mourvedre bottlings -- in the next 6-8 years -- but it could easily surprise us and go longer.
- Production: 306 cases
- List Price: $55 VINsider Price: $44
2022 SYRAH
- Production Notes: Syrah often seems to shrug off the challenges of hot years. In 2022, much of it was already harvested before our early-September heat wave, and the resulting wines showed a lovely dark color and welcome vibrancy that balanced the grape's black fruit and spice notes. We ferment our Syrah in open-top fermenters, punched down twice daily, then move it to barrel to complete fermentation. For our varietal bottling we selected lots with good natural acidity and lushness to balance the grape's tannic density, about 90% from neutral oak and 10% from new barriques. The selected lots were blended in June 2023 and aged in neutral oak until bottling in April 2024.
- Tasting Notes: A deep, rich nose of barbeque rub, teriyaki, and elderberry, with refreshing wintergreen and crushed rock minerality providing lift. The mouth shows notes of flourless chocolate cake, complete with blackcurrant reduction, a little minty lift, and a long finish where chalky tannins provide framework for the salted black licorice and blackberry notes. A lovely Syrah that should age effortlessly for two decades.
- Production: 656 cases
- List Price: $55 VINsider Price: $44
If you're a wine club member, we've got a few different ways you can try these wines. We are hosting a live in-person pickup party here at the winery on Sunday, April 6th. Neil, Chelsea, and I will also be hosting another virtual pickup party the evening of Friday, March 28th. And we'll again be offering club members who visit between March 14th and April 5th the opportunity to choose their shipment wines as their tasting flight.
If you're not a wine club member, and you've read all this way, we'd love to have you join while there's still a chance to get this spring shipment. Details and how to join are at tablascreek.com/wine_club/vinsider_club.